# Should you hire a social media manager, an agency, or use a tool? How to decide based on what's missing

> A framework for deciding based on how much you post, how many messages you get, who sets the strategy and who controls your brand. What each option covers, how to combine them and how to find out what it costs where you are.


**Decide based on the work that isn't getting done today.** If you know what to post and what's missing is the time to produce it, schedule it and reply, a tool is usually enough. If what's missing is someone to decide what to say, talk with your community every day and know your business, you need a person: a social media manager on your team or a freelancer. If you need strategy, design, video and ads at once and don't have time to coordinate several vendors, an agency gives you that team with one point of contact. Many small businesses end up with a mix: a person who makes the calls and a tool that takes the repetitive work off their plate.

This page doesn't give salaries or rates. We didn't find a primary source that publishes them for the countries this site is read in, and what shows up in search results are estimates from job sites and from the vendors themselves. Further down, we explain how to find out what it costs in your market.

## Three businesses, three answers

*Fictional cases, to show how the decision changes for the same question.*

- **An optician with two stores.** It posts three times a week on Instagram and Facebook. The owner knows what she wants to show (new frames, opening hours, insurance plans) and takes good photos on her phone. She gets about forty messages a week, almost all asking about hours, the price of an eye exam or whether a frame is in stock. She's short on time, not judgment: **a tool** that schedules posts, answers the repeat questions and hands her the ones it can't.
- **A dental clinic launching clear aligners.** It has no photos of its own, no content plan and no ads set up, and wants to launch in two months. It needs strategy, a photo shoot, video and a paid campaign at the same time. **An agency** for the launch period gives it all of that under one contract. Once the launch is over, it can move to a person or a tool.
- **A skincare brand that sells online.** It gets hundreds of comments a week, with complaints about shipping and questions about ingredients that need careful answers. It needs **a person** who knows the product and moderates every day, and that person gets more done with **a tool** that organizes the inbox and drafts replies.

## What each option covers and what it doesn't

| Option | Covers | Doesn't cover | Wins when |
| --- | --- | --- | --- |
| In-house social media manager | Knows the business from the inside, talks with the community, has judgment for sensitive cases and coordinates with sales or support | Design, video or ads unless they're part of the job; coverage when they're on vacation or out sick | Your community is central to how you sell or support customers, and there's work every day |
| Freelance social media manager | The same judgment and conversation, part time and without creating a position | Immediate replies if they work with several clients; anything outside the agreed hours | You need judgment, but not a full-time role |
| Agency | A team with several specialties (strategy, design, video, ads) under one contract and one point of contact | Deep knowledge of your business from month one; speed, if every piece goes through several people | You need production and strategy at once, or don't want to coordinate several vendors |
| Tool, including AI agents | Scheduling and publishing across networks, organizing messages, drafting posts and reports; AI tools also write and reply within the rules you set | Setting the strategy, filming your product or your store, looking after your relationship with your community, handling a sensitive complaint | You already know what to say and lack the time, or want one person to get more done |

If you're thinking about building your own agent on a general AI model, count it as one more tool, with an added cost: connecting it to each network, giving it permissions and checking what it does falls on you.

## Seven questions that tip the decision

### 1. How much do you post, and on how many networks?

Count your posts from the last four weeks, network by network, and separate the pieces that had to be produced from the posts. One video on Instagram and Facebook is one piece and two posts; the difference is explained in [how to put together a social media management proposal](/en/guides/social-media-management-proposal/). If you post a little and use material you already have, a tool is enough. If it's a lot of pieces made from scratch, you need a person or an agency to produce them.

### 2. Does someone need to decide what to say?

If you don't have a goal for the month or aren't clear on who you're talking to, a tool will just carry out a plan that doesn't exist, faster. That work belongs to a person: you, a social media manager with strategy experience, or an agency. How strategy and community conversation split between roles is covered in [what a community manager does](/en/guides/what-is-a-community-manager/).

### 3. Does your content need to be filmed or photographed?

No tool shows up at your store. If what you post depends on showing your product, your team or your customers, someone has to be there: you, someone on your team, a social media manager who films, or an agency with production.

### 4. How many messages do you get, and how sensitive are they?

Take one week of comments and direct messages and sort them into two groups. In the first, the ones you can answer with information you already have: hours, published prices, shipping. In the second, the ones that need judgment: a complaint, a health question, a refund. A tool can draft or answer the first group, with your approval. The second needs a person with the authority to resolve it. If the second group is large every week, hire that person before anything else.

### 5. How much can you spend per month, and on what?

Many tools publish their price. A person or an agency has a price that depends on the scope you ask for. To compare, put all three options against the same work, using the method in the section on cost below. Always keep the fee separate from the money that goes to ads: they're two different budgets.

### 6. Who controls the brand and the accounts?

Whichever option you pick, the accounts should stay in your business's name, and the person you hire gets their own permission instead of your password, where the network allows it. Which permission to give each person based on their task, and how to hand over access when someone leaves, is in [social media team roles and permissions](/en/guides/social-media-team-roles-permissions/). On Instagram, that option is called Shared access and it isn't available on every account: the steps and conditions are in [how to give someone access to your Instagram without your password](/en/solutions/instagram-shared-access/). Put in writing who owns the content that gets produced: the [Freelancers Union Contract Creator](https://freelancersunion.org/contract/) includes, among its optional terms, one for "Ownership," one for "Revisions/Changes" and one for a "Cancellation Fee." And decide who approves before anything goes live; the [content approval workflow](/en/guides/social-media-content-approval-workflow/) explains how to close each round.

### 7. How many brands or accounts are there?

With a single brand, any of the options works. With several (locations with their own accounts, several businesses with the same owner, or if you're the agency), keeping each one's voice, materials and approvals apart becomes the main problem, and it weighs on which person and which tool you choose. What to keep separate is in [how to manage multiple brands on social media](/en/guides/manage-multiple-brands-social-media/).

## When a tool isn't enough

You're better off with a person or an agency, with the tool as something that person uses, when:

- You don't have a strategy or the time to set one.
- Your content needs on-site production, or a level of design or video nobody on your team has.
- Your community regularly brings sensitive cases (health, money, public complaints) and nobody can review them daily.
- Nobody is going to set the rules or review what gets published. An AI tool needs someone to tell it what it can answer on its own and what it has to hand to a person.

And the other way around: if you post a little, know what to say and your messages are mostly the same questions, an agency or a full-time hire is probably more than you need.

## Combinations that work

- **A person with a tool.** The social media manager decides and talks with the community; the tool schedules, organizes the inbox and drafts. When hiring, ask which tool they use and whether they can work in accounts owned by your business.
- **An agency with your approval.** The agency produces and publishes, and you approve each piece before it goes out. Put it in the proposal: how many review rounds there are, and that silence doesn't count as approval.
- **You with a tool and a freelancer per project.** You handle the day to day and bring in a photo shoot or a launch when you need one.

## How much does it cost to hire a social media manager or an agency?

We don't give you a number, for the reason above: salaries and rates change by country, city, experience and scope, and we didn't find a primary source that collects them. Here's what you can do to find out what it costs in your market:

1. **Write the scope before you ask for a price.** Networks, pieces produced per month, posts, hours for answering messages, review rounds, monthly report, and what isn't included (for example, the money for ads). The [social media management proposal](/en/guides/social-media-management-proposal/) has a full example you can adapt.
2. **Ask for three quotes using that same document.** For example, two freelance social media managers and one agency. If each one quotes a different scope, you can't compare them.
3. **Compare on the same unit.** What each price includes, who supplies the photos, whether ads are separate, whether there's a minimum contract term and what you get back if you end it (files, access, calendar).
4. **If you're hiring an employee, add what your country requires on top of the salary,** and get clear on whether the relationship is employment or a service contract: it doesn't depend on what you call it. In the United States, for example, the [IRS](https://www.irs.gov/businesses/small-businesses-self-employed/independent-contractor-self-employed-or-employee) says "it is critical that business owners correctly determine whether the individuals providing services are employees" or independent contractors, and it looks at control over the work, the financial side and the type of relationship. In your country, check with the labor or tax authority, or an accountant.
5. **For the tool, check the published price and what each plan includes.** If there's a trial, use it on a real week of your brand: [what to test before choosing an AI tool](/en/guides/evaluate-ai-tools-social-media-managers/) lays out three concrete tests.

## Questions to evaluate each one

### For a social media manager, in-house or freelance

- Show me an account you ran: what did you decide, and what were you asked to do?
- You get this comment (paste a real complaint from your account): what do you reply, and who do you pass it to?
- What hours can you cover, and who fills in if you're out?
- Which tools do you work with, and can you do it with access from my business instead of my password?
- What will you report to me each month, and with what data?

### For an agency

- Who runs my account day to day, and who do I talk to if there's a problem?
- How many review rounds does each piece include, and how do I approve?
- Who answers messages, during what hours, and which cases come to me?
- Is ad spend separate from the fee?
- If we end the contract, what do I get back, and whose name are the accounts in?

### For a tool

- Does it publish on every network I use?
- What does it do on its own, and what needs my approval?
- How does it flag a message it shouldn't answer?
- How many people can log in, and how does a client or partner approve without an account?
- Is there a trial, and what does it cost afterward?

## Where HeyMark fits

HeyMark is one of the options on the tool side. It's an AI agent that plans, creates, publishes, replies and analyzes on Instagram, TikTok, Facebook, LinkedIn and YouTube. It replies to comments and DMs with AI in your brand's voice, with approval and handoff to a person. Every plan includes a client approval link, and the Company plan includes 5 people, so it fits the combinations above: a social media manager or an agency working with the tool, and a client who approves. There's no free plan: every plan starts with a 7-day free trial, and prices are on the [pricing page](/en/pricing/). If you're the agency, the page for [social media agencies](/en/solutions/agencies/) explains how each client is kept separate.

**What stays with you.**
HeyMark doesn't set your strategy, film your product or take over your relationship with your community. Those decisions still belong to a person: you or whoever you hire. If your brand uses a network beyond those five, check that before you choose.

## Plan your next post in HeyMark.

Keep the idea, review the draft with your team, and see how it performed in the accounts you connected.

[Start free](https://app.heymark.ai) · [See how it works](https://heymark.ai/en/#product)

## Developer and agent resources

- [HeyMark MCP documentation](https://heymark.ai/en/mcp/)
- [llms.txt](https://heymark.ai/llms.txt)
- [Full site content for language models](https://heymark.ai/llms-full.txt)
- MCP protocol endpoint: `POST https://mcp.heymark.ai`
- OAuth protected-resource metadata: [/.well-known/oauth-protected-resource](https://mcp.heymark.ai/.well-known/oauth-protected-resource)
- MCP server card: [/server-card](https://mcp.heymark.ai/server-card)
