HeyMark
Content

Blog

Marketing benchmarking: what to compare and how

HeyMark3 min read
Two wooden trays show different ways of organizing stones.

Marketing benchmarking compares a process, service, or outcome with a reference to identify differences and decide what to investigate. A baseline is your current performance; a benchmark is a point of reference, often external. ASQ defines benchmarking as comparing products, services, or processes with recognized organizations to identify opportunities for improvement. A comparison alone cannot tell you which change will work.

Start by choosing what to compare

A whole campaign mixes many variables. Narrow the question to one task, such as preparing a proposal, reviewing a landing page, or delivering a report. Record the scope, unit, period, when the measurement starts and stops, exclusions, and quality criteria. Without these definitions, two figures with the same label may describe different work.

This also differs from social media competitor analysis: reviewing other brands’ posts and formats asks what they communicate; process benchmarking looks at how a task is done or what comparable result it produces.

Example: a proposal baseline and internal trial

Suppose a team records an internal median of 72 hours from receiving a complete brief to sending a proposal. This figure is invented to illustrate the method, not an industry standard. The team proposes testing a workflow that targets 48 hours while keeping scope, quality review, and the timing rule unchanged.

First, confirm a baseline using the same measurement rule. Then compare an equivalent trial period and record volume, included tasks, waiting time, and rework. If turnaround falls but errors, incomplete proposals, or lower conversion increase, there is not enough evidence to expand the change. The 72 and 48 hours are internal experimental figures, not industry data.

Comparing an external reference

APQC distinguishes a baseline from a benchmark: the former describes current performance; the latter provides a reference. Before interpreting a gap, check that the measure’s definition, scope, unit, period, and data quality match, and note contextual differences such as organization size, channel, or campaign mix.

For instance, APQC’s measure for the time to develop and launch a marketing campaign defines the cycle from ideation through delivery and includes both work and wait time. Its published median describes that measure and shows why the definition matters; it is not an automatic target for every marketing team.

A practical process is to frame the question, agree on a metric and its start and end points, measure the baseline, find a comparable reference, explain the gap, form a hypothesis, and test a small change. Record missing data too. If the reference is not comparable, treat it as a question to investigate, not a numeric target.

What not to conclude

A difference does not prove that copying another organization’s practice will produce the same result. Metrics can vary with sector, budget, audience, channel, and quality criteria. Avoid presenting averages as promises or universal targets; use the comparison to decide what to investigate and measure the effect in your own context.

If your benchmarks are specific Instagram accounts and you want to know when one of them has a post doing much better than usual, the step-by-step method is in Instagram competitor tracking.

Plan your next post in HeyMark.

Keep the idea, review the draft with your team, and see how it performed in the accounts you connected.