HeyMark

Instagram competitor tracking: how to tell when one of their posts takes off

By HeyMark · Updated

If you run social media for a business, there are accounts you keep an eye on: your direct competitors, a brand that does your format well or a standout account in your industry. This page helps you find out when one of them gets a post that performs far better than usual, without opening their profiles every day, and see how they evolve week by week. First you’ll see what data from another account is visible, then a manual method with a spreadsheet and, at the end, how HeyMark does it.

What you can and can’t see on a competitor’s Instagram

On a public account you see what any visitor sees: the profile, the posts and whatever counts the account leaves visible. You can’t see its insights. Instagram’s insights describe your own account and your content (Instagram Help on insights); another account’s insights belong to that account, unless it shares them with you.

Data On someone else’s public account Details
Followers and number of posts You see it It’s on the profile.
Likes on each post You see them, unless the account hides them The person posting can hide like and view counts on each post from others, and still sees the total (Instagram Help).
Comments Usually, you see them The person posting can also hide some counts, according to the Instagram API reference.
Views On some formats, unless hidden They’re hidden together with likes.
Saves No The Instagram API returns saves only to the person who posted or an accepted collaborator (IG Media reference).
How many accounts saw it, who engaged, audience data No These are the owner account’s insights.

Before you conclude that an account hides its likes, check your own setting. Instagram lets you stop seeing counts on other accounts’ posts, and if you turned that on you won’t see anyone’s. It’s covered in how to hide or show like counts on Instagram.

Track Instagram competitors by hand: a spreadsheet and the median

What you’re looking for is a post that performs far above normal for that account. Comparing a neighborhood bakery with a chain won’t tell you that: each account is compared with itself.

  1. Pick a few accounts and note why each one is there. A direct competitor, a brand that posts in your format or an account from another industry that speaks to your audience. If you don’t know why you follow an account, you won’t know what to do when it takes off either.
  2. Make one row per post with the account, the link, the post date, the format, likes, comments, interactions (likes plus comments), how many times it beats the median and a note on the topic or hook.
  3. Check once a week, on the same day. Log each post only once, when it’s at least three days old: newer posts are still adding up and wait for the next check. The posts won’t all be exactly the same age, but that’s enough to notice a threefold jump. In the same check, log each account’s followers: that’s how you see how they evolve.
  4. Work out each account’s median from its last 9 to 12 posts. Sort them from lowest to highest by interactions and take the middle one; with an even number, the average of the two middle ones.
  5. Divide each new post by that median. If you get 3 or more, flag it. The 3 is a rule of thumb, not an Instagram rule: it’s the same one HeyMark’s alert uses, as you’ll see below, and you can raise or lower it if an account is very steady or very uneven.

The median doesn’t move because of a single hit; the average does. One viral post inflates the average, and after that it’s harder for another one to stand out. The difference is explained step by step in mean vs median.

Fictional example: Northside Bakery

Northside Bakery is made up for this example, and so are its numbers. These are its last nine posts:

Post Format Likes Comments Interactions
1 Photo 198 12 210
2 Carousel 171 9 180
3 Reel 244 16 260
4 Photo 186 9 195
5 Carousel 227 13 240
6 Reel 958 62 1,020
7 Photo 207 13 220
8 Carousel 166 9 175
9 Reel 218 12 230

Sorted from lowest to highest, the interactions are 175, 180, 195, 210, 220, 230, 240, 260 and 1,020. The fifth, the middle one, is 220: that’s the median. The average of all nine is 2,730 ÷ 9 = 303, higher because of the 1,020 Reel.

Post 10 comes in, a Reel with 681 likes and 39 comments: 720 interactions.

  • Against the median: 720 ÷ 220 = 3.3 times. It gets flagged.
  • Against the average: 720 ÷ 303 = 2.4 times. With the average, the earlier hit would have hidden it.

If Northside Bakery hid its likes, you’d do the same with comments only. The median of its nine posts is 12 comments and the new Reel has 39: 39 ÷ 12 = 3.25 times, so it gets flagged too. What you shouldn’t do is mix them: an account measured on comments only isn’t comparable with one measured on likes and comments.

When you find a flagged post, note what’s different about it: the topic, the format, the first few seconds, the time, whether there was a collaboration or a giveaway. That’s an observation, not yet a recipe. To turn it into a test for your own account, follow the social media competitor analysis method. If you want to compare your results with an external reference more rigorously, see marketing benchmarking.

How HeyMark does it with Benchmarks

In HeyMark, Benchmarks does this tracking for public Instagram accounts, without the spreadsheet or the weekly check.

  • The table. “How your benchmarks have evolved” puts your brand at the top and each benchmark account below it, with followers, average likes and engagement.
  • The alert, account by account. You turn the alert on for the accounts you care about. When a post from that account gets 3 times or more its median interactions, an alert lands in the HeyMark app’s notifications; accounts are checked once a day.
  • Asking your assistant. If you connect Claude or ChatGPT to HeyMark, you can ask it “What did my benchmarks post this week?”

Limits of competitor tracking

  • Public Instagram accounts only. Benchmarks follows public Instagram accounts; a private account is left out.
  • Hidden likes. If an account hides its likes, the number doesn’t show in the Instagram app, and the Instagram API doesn’t return it either when it’s read indirectly, as when you query another account: the IG Media reference says like_count is omitted in that case. For that account, manual tracking works with less data: use comments only, as in the example.
  • Not every public account is within the API’s reach. The Instagram API query for reading data about another account, called business discovery, returns Business or Creator accounts, and doesn’t return data about age-gated Business accounts (business discovery reference). If an Instagram competitor analysis tool can’t find an account, that may be why.
  • Counts don’t explain why. A post can take off because of a collaboration, a giveaway or paid promotion, and public counts can’t tell them apart. They don’t show sales or reach either.
  • Ads are separate. What your competitors spend on advertising is checked in each platform’s ad library and isn’t part of this tracking.

Frequently asked questions

Can I compare likes between two accounts of different sizes?

Not directly: an account with 90,000 followers gets more likes than one with 18,000 without that telling you who posts better. To spot a post that takes off, compare each account with its own median. To compare accounts with each other, use median interactions per post ÷ followers × 100 and note the date of the follower count.

Should I add a Reel's views to its interactions?

Better not. A view and a like measure different things, and not every post shows views. If they're useful to you, log them in a separate column and compare them only across Reels from the same account.

See it on your own accounts.

Connect Instagram, TikTok, Facebook, LinkedIn or YouTube and use HeyMark free for 7 days. Mark answers in your voice, and you approve what goes out.

Keep reading