HeyMark
Content

Blog Marketing

Omnichannel vs multichannel: differences and an example

HeyMark5 min read
Paper bag, receipt and phone beside a box of bread on a counter.

A multichannel business serves customers through two or more channels; an omnichannel business coordinates those channels so a person can continue a task with consistent information and service. The distinction depends on how well the journey connects, not on how many accounts, stores or platforms the business has.

Lehrer and Trenz’s academic review defines omnichannel business through integrated processes and systems that support a consistent experience across physical and digital channels. It identifies six dimensions: channel transitions and customer experience, plus the integration of information systems, channel management, incentives and logistics. It also describes the move from multichannel to omnichannel as gradual and notes its technological, organizational and operational changes (“Omnichannel Business,” Electronic Markets).

Omnichannel vs. multichannel marketing

A fictional bookshop has a physical store and an online catalogue. Having both makes it multichannel. If a customer checks a book online and then visits the store, the experience depends on whether information, stock and service can carry over from one channel to the other.

Dimension Channels managed separately Integration to develop
Transition The customer has to explain again which book they searched for or asked about. They can continue an inquiry or order when moving from the website to the shop.
Experience Opening hours, terms or answers may differ by channel. Information and terms stay consistent at each touchpoint.
Information systems Catalogue and stock records are updated separately. Staff can check records that work together and stay current across channels.
Channel management Each channel has disconnected owners and priorities. Responsibilities account for tasks that cross channels.
Incentives and goals Each team may measure only its own sales or direct contacts. Measures recognize shared work on one purchase or service request.
Logistics Reservation, payment, pickup or returns are limited to the channel where a purchase began. Delivery, pickup or returns are coordinated according to the available terms.

The six dimensions come from Lehrer and Trenz’s framework; the bookshop situations are an editorial application. A business does not need to integrate everything to improve one journey. It can start with the point that makes a customer repeat steps, provided it can keep the information current and deliver what it promises.

Example: reserve a book and pick it up at the shop

In this fictional scenario, the online catalogue does not show live stock. A customer sends the title they want to reserve through the contact form. Someone at the shop checks inventory, replies with availability and, if the customer agrees, holds the book until closing time the next day. The customer pays at pickup.

That manual handoff connects the catalogue with in-store service and offers a first step across channels. It still depends on someone checking and updating the reservation. It cannot promise immediate availability, and it does not make the bookshop a fully integrated omnichannel business by itself.

To make the handoff workable, the bookshop would need to say that requests require confirmation, assign someone to check messages, set a response time and record each hold in a shared place. Before travelling, the customer needs to know the title, location, hold deadline and payment method. If staff cannot handle requests promptly, the shop could limit reservation hours or offer the channel for inquiries without automatically confirming stock.

To make the handoff concrete, the fictional shop handles requests Monday to Saturday from 10 a.m. to 6 p.m. and promises a reply within the next two service hours: outside that window, the clock resumes when the shop next opens. The initial notice says that submitting the form does not yet reserve stock. After checking availability and receiving the customer’s agreement, the shop sends a confirmation like this:

Your copy of Treasure Island is reserved at our city-center shop until 6 p.m. tomorrow. Pay when you collect it. Give the counter staff code R24 so they can find your reservation. If you need a different deadline, reply to this message before closing.

Code R24 links the confirmation to the held copy and lets another staff member find the order. The team records who set it aside and clears the hold when it is collected or expires, preventing the same copy from being offered to two people. The title, code and hours are conditions of this fictional case.

How to move toward a more integrated experience

Choose a common task that crosses channels, such as checking a product online and picking it up in a store. Map what the customer does and what information each step needs. Then find where information gets lost, who can fix it and which system keeps the record current.

Start with a small connection you can operate and review. Record requests, confirmations, stock errors and repeated questions. If the manual process holds up, assess which information or logistics integration would address the next limit. Lehrer and Trenz describe the transition as gradual; technology investment and organizational change can also be costly and risky. Adding channels without the capacity to serve them can increase complexity.

A journey map helps document actions and touchpoints from the customer’s perspective. The customer journey map guide explains how to separate observations from assumptions. Measuring which channel received the last click does not by itself show that the journey is integrated. The question here is whether the task can continue and the information carries over.

The cover is an AI-generated illustration.

Plan your next post in HeyMark.

Keep the idea, review the draft with your team, and see how it performed in the accounts you connected.