HeyMark
Content

Blog

Facebook vs Instagram for business: where should you put your effort?

9 min read

If you can only do one network well, pick the one your customers use. In the US, age and location are the best clues: if your customers are 50 or older, or live in a rural area, Facebook wins by a wide margin; if they’re 18 to 29, Instagram; between 30 and 49, a majority say they use each one, so decide by what you can produce every week. The figures come from Pew Research Center’s social media fact sheet, which covers US adults only (survey conducted January 30 to June 18, 2026). In it, 70% of adults say they use Facebook and 51% say they use Instagram, and Facebook leads in every group Pew reports except one: among 18 to 29 year olds, 79% say they use Instagram and 69% Facebook. The rule is ours.

Choosing one doesn’t mean dropping the other. Both are managed from Meta Business Suite, and from the Instagram app you can share each post to your Facebook Page. What you’re really deciding is which network you design content for, where you answer messages first, and where you measure. Outside the US we didn’t use comparable survey data; there, the answer comes from the four-week test at the end. We read every source on this page on November 20, 2026.

Who uses each network in the US

Pew’s fact sheet, published October 19, 2026, is based on a survey of 5,511 US adults conducted online, by mail and by phone, with an overall margin of error of plus or minus 1.8 percentage points. It measures who says they ever use each platform.

Group Facebook Instagram Gap
All adults 70% 51% 19 points, Facebook ahead
Ages 18 to 29 69% 79% 10 points, Instagram ahead
Ages 30 to 49 78% 64% 14 points, Facebook ahead
Ages 50 to 64 71% 41% 30 points, Facebook ahead
Ages 65 and older 59% 21% 38 points, Facebook ahead
Women 77% 56% 21 points, Facebook ahead
Men 63% 45% 18 points, Facebook ahead
Hispanic 70% 60% 10 points, Facebook ahead
Urban 67% 58% 9 points, Facebook ahead
Suburban 69% 54% 15 points, Facebook ahead
Rural 76% 40% 36 points, Facebook ahead

What this changes in your decision, all within the US:

  • The gap widens with age. Between 30 and 49, a majority say they use each network (78% and 64%), so the audience doesn’t decide for you. From 50 up, far more people say they use Facebook, and from 65 up, almost three times as many (59% versus 21%).
  • Where people live matters as much as age. In rural areas, 76% say they use Facebook and 40% Instagram. In cities the gap shrinks to 9 points. A small-town business and a downtown one don’t get the same answer, even if they sell the same thing.
  • Facebook held steady and Instagram grew. In Pew’s surveys since 2016, Facebook has stayed between 68% and 71%. Instagram went from 28% in 2016 to 51% in 2026. Pew notes that the survey method changed over those years (phone through 2021; online and mail in 2023; online, mail and phone from 2024).
  • “Ever use” doesn’t say how much. The fact sheet doesn’t report how often people use each network or whether they follow brands there. Someone who says they use Facebook may not open it daily or ever buy from you there.

Where to start, based on your customer

This table applies the figures above to typical cases. The figures are Pew’s and US only; the recommendation is ours. If your market is in another country, treat the table as a hypothesis and check it with the test at the end.

If your customer looks like this Start with Why
A neighborhood optician whose customers are mostly 50 to 70 Facebook 71% versus 41% among 50 to 64 year olds, and 59% versus 21% from 65 up
A secondhand clothing shop that sells to students Instagram It’s the only age group where Instagram leads: 79% versus 69%
A preschool that talks to parents aged 30 to 45 A majority say they use each (78% and 64%): decide by what you can keep up If you can film vertical video every week, design for Instagram and share to Facebook; if not, Facebook with photos and text is enough
A hardware store in a small town or rural area Facebook 76% versus 40% in rural areas
A business that sells through messages (orders, bookings, quotes) The network where people already message you Both have business messaging; before you choose, count where last month’s messages came from

If you don’t know your customers’ age, don’t guess: it’s the first thing you write down in the four-week test.

What each one offers for selling, according to Meta

Meta has a business page for each network. Neither compares one network with the other or says which one sells more.

Facebook. The Facebook for business page suggests you “Create a Facebook business Page,” “Chat with customers using Messenger for Business,” “Boost a post to engage new audiences,” use scheduled posts and “Use Page Insights to learn about your customers,” along with Ads Manager. If you’re unsure between a Page and a profile in professional mode, we compare them in Facebook Page vs professional mode.

Instagram. The Instagram for business page says: “Share content and try different formats like posts, Stories, and Reels to get the word out about your business.” It also suggests using Instagram Direct to encourage subscriptions, appointments and questions, and Instagram ads to send people to your physical store or your website. To see insights and create ads you need a professional account, which gives you the professional dashboard; if your personal account is private, switching to professional makes it public. If you’re not sure which type to pick, see Instagram business vs creator accounts.

Both pages link to “Shops” in their tools menu, but neither explains in the text what it includes or which countries it’s available in. We didn’t check it for your country: confirm before you count on selling inside the app.

The Facebook for business page shows daily and monthly Facebook usage figures, but their footnotes didn’t appear when we read it, so we don’t know what date they’re from and we don’t use them.

They’re managed together: how much work that saves

From one place. According to the Meta Business Suite page, that tool manages your business activity on Facebook, Messenger and Instagram: you can “create or schedule posts, stories and ads,” view notifications, respond to messages and check insights. What each Meta tool does and whether it costs anything is in what is Meta Business Suite.

Post once to both. Instagram’s help page on sharing to Facebook says that once you add your accounts to Accounts Center, you can share a post to your Facebook Page with “Also share on…” before you publish it, or have every post shared automatically. Two conditions: the feature is only for the Instagram app on Android or iPhone, and the audience for what you share to Facebook may differ from the audience for your Facebook posts. The steps, the Page requirements and what to check if your Page doesn’t show up are in how to share Instagram posts to Facebook.

Sharing doesn’t make a post perform the same on both. Each network shows it to whoever it chooses, and on Facebook a large share of what people see in Feed now comes from recommendations, as we explain in Facebook organic reach. That’s why the test below measures each network separately.

Decide with your own numbers in four weeks

Outside the US, this is the part that answers the question. The timeframes and quantities are our suggestion; adjust them, but set them before you start.

Pick one metric based on what you want from social media: messages if you sell through conversations, website visits if you sell online, new followers if people are still getting to know you. How to give each network a different job is in the guide to social media strategy.

When What you do What you write down
Before you start Check your Instagram follower insights and Facebook’s professional dashboard. Ask your next ten customers which network they use and how they found you Age and top locations of your Instagram followers; Facebook reach and net followers; the ten answers
Weeks 1 to 4 Post three pieces a week, the same on both networks and on the same day, with no paid promotion For each piece, at 7 days: reach and new followers. Per week and per network: messages that came in and website visits from that network
At the end Compare the metric you picked, network by network: for new followers, the median of the twelve pieces (not the best one); for messages or visits, the four-week total The metric you picked at the start, network by network

Where each figure lives, according to official help:

  • Instagram: Instagram’s insights help says that with a public account and at least 100 followers you can see how many you gained or lost, their top locations, their age range and the times they’re most active, for timeframes within the past 90 days. It shows who follows you today, not who would buy from you, but it’s enough to see whether your real audience looks like Pew’s table.
  • Facebook: the professional dashboard is available for Pages in the new Pages experience and for profiles in professional mode, on the mobile app and on desktop, and its overview shows reach, engagement, net followers and 3-second video views for up to the past 90 days.
  • Your customers: the ten answers are worth more than any national average, because they’re your market.

Example rule, our suggestion: if one network brings in at least two thirds of the metric you picked over the four weeks, that’s where the content you make with one network in mind goes, and the other gets what you share. If they come out even, keep both and design for whichever is cheaper for you to produce. Don’t add up reach on both networks as if it were different people: someone may have seen you on both.

If after the test you keep both, or you’re also wondering about TikTok (we cover that in is TikTok good for business), HeyMark plans and publishes to Instagram, Facebook, TikTok, LinkedIn and YouTube, and lets you schedule social media posts across networks from a single upload.

Plan your next post in HeyMark.

Keep the idea, review the draft with your team, and see how it performed in the accounts you connected.